Motivation:
So far, we generated and deployed test JARs to Maven repositories. The
deployed JAR had the classifier 'test-jar'. The test JAR is consumed by
transport-native-epoll as a test dependency.
The problem is, when netty-transport-native-epoll pulls the test JAR as
a dependency, that Maven resolves its transitive dependencies at
'compile' and 'runtime' scope only, which is incorrect.
I was bitten by this problem recently while trying to add a new
dependency to netty-testsuite. Because I added a new dependency at the
'test' scope, the new dependency was not pulled transitively by
transport-native-epoll and caused an unexpected build failure.
- d6160208c3
- bf77bb4c3a
Modifications:
- Move all classes in netty-testsuite from src/test to src/main
- Update the 'compile' scope dependencies of netty-testsuite
- Override the test directory configuration properties of the surefire
plugin
- Do not generate the test JAR anymore
- Update the dependency of netty-transport-native-epoll
Result:
It is less error-prone to add a new dependency to netty-testsuite.
Motivation:
Everytime a new connection is accepted via EpollSocketServerChannel it will create a new EpollSocketChannel that needs to get the remote and local addresses in the constructor. The current implementation uses new InetSocketAddress(String, int) to create these. This is quite slow due the implementation in oracle and openjdk.
Modifications:
Encode all needed informations into a byte array before return from jni layer and then use new InetSocketAddress(InetAddress, int) to create the socket addresses. This allows to create the InetAddress via a byte[] and so reduce the overhead, this is done either by using InetAddress.getByteAddress(byte[]) or by Inet6Address.getByteAddress(String, byte[], int).
Result:
Reduce performance overhead while accept new connections with native transport
Motivation:
So far, our TLS renegotiation test did not test changing cipher suite
during renegotiation explicitly.
Modifications:
- Switch the cipher suite during renegotiation
Result:
We are now sure the cipher suite change works.
Motivation:
We only provided a constructor in DefaultFileRegion that takes a FileChannel which means the File itself needs to get opened on construction. This has the problem that if you want to write a lot of Files very fast you may end up with may open FD's even if they are not needed yet. This can lead to hit the open FD limit of the OS.
Modifications:
Add a new constructor to DefaultFileRegion which allows to construct it from a File. The FileChannel will only be obtained when transferTo(...) is called or the DefaultFileRegion is explicit open'ed via open() (this is needed for the native epoll transport)
Result:
Less resource usage when writing a lot of DefaultFileRegion.
Related: #3125
Motivation:
We did not expose a way to initiate TLS renegotiation and to get
notified when the renegotiation is done.
Modifications:
- Add SslHandler.renegotiate() so that a user can initiate TLS
renegotiation and get the future that's notified on completion
- Make SslHandler.handshakeFuture() return the future for the most
recent handshake so that a user can get the future of the last
renegotiation
- Add the test for renegotiation to SocketSslEchoTest
Result:
Both client-initiated and server-initiated renegotiations are now
supported properly.
Motivation:
JDK's exception messages triggered by a connection attempt failure do
not contain the related remote address in its message. We currently
append the remote address to ConnectException's message, but I found
that we need to cover more exception types such as SocketException.
Modifications:
- Add AbstractUnsafe.annotateConnectException() to de-duplicate the
code that appends the remote address
Result:
- Less duplication
- A transport implementor can annotate connection attempt failure
message more easily
Motivation:
We use malloc(1) in the on JNI_OnLoad method but never free the allocated memory. This means we have a tiny memory leak of 1 byte.
Modifications:
Call free(...) on previous allocated memory.
Result:
Fix memory leak
Motiviation:
If sendmmsg is already defined then the native epoll module failed to build because of conflicting definitions.
The mmsghdr type was also redefined on systems that already supported this structure.
Modifications:
Provide a way so that systems which already define sendmmsg and mmsghdr can build
Provide a way so that systems which don't define sendmmsg and mmsghdr can build
Result:
The native EPOLL module can build in more environments
Motivation:
In linux it is possible to write more then one buffer withone syscall when sending datagram messages.
Modifications:
Not copy CompositeByteBuf if it only contains direct buffers.
Result:
More performance due less overhead for copy.
Motivation:
On linux with glibc >= 2.14 it is possible to send multiple DatagramPackets with one syscall. This can be a huge performance win and so we should support it in our native transport.
Modification:
- Add support for sendmmsg by reuse IovArray
- Factor out ThreadLocal support of IovArray to IovArrayThreadLocal for better separation as we use IovArray also without ThreadLocal in NativeDatagramPacketArray now
- Introduce NativeDatagramPacketArray which is used for sendmmsg(...)
- Implement sendmmsg(...) via jni
- Expand DatagramUnicastTest to test also sendmmsg(...)
Result:
Netty now automatically use sendmmsg(...) if it is supported and we have more then 1 DatagramPacket in the ChannelOutboundBuffer and flush() is called.
Motivation:
On linux it is possible to use the sendMsg(...) system call to write multiple buffers with one system call when using datagram/udp.
Modifications:
- Implement the needed changes and make use of sendMsg(...) if possible for max performance
- Add tests that test sending datagram packets with all kind of different ByteBuf implementations.
Result:
Performance improvement when using CompoisteByteBuf and EpollDatagramChannel.
Motivation:
InetAddress.getByName(...) uses exceptions for control flow when try to parse IPv4-mapped-on-IPv6 addresses. This is quite expensive.
Modifications:
Detect IPv4-mapped-on-IPv6 addresses in the JNI level and convert to IPv4 addresses before pass to InetAddress.getByName(...) (via InetSocketAddress constructor).
Result:
Eliminate performance problem causes by exception creation when parsing IPv4-mapped-on-IPv6 addresses.
Motivation:
In EpollSocketchannel.doWriteFileRegion(...) we need to make sure we write until sendFile(...) returns either 0 or all is written. Otherwise we may not get notified once the Channel is writable again.
This is the case as we use EPOLL_ET.
Modifications:
Always write until either sendFile returns 0 or all is written.
Result:
No more hangs when writing DefaultFileRegion can happen.
Motivation:
There were no way to efficient write a CompositeByteBuf as we always did a memory copy to a direct buffer in this case. This is not needed as we can just write a CompositeByteBuf as long as all the components are buffers with a memory address.
Modifications:
- Write CompositeByteBuf which contains only direct buffers without memory copy
- Also handle CompositeByteBuf that have more components then 1024.
Result:
More efficient writing of CompositeByteBuf.
Related issue: #2764
Motivation:
EpollSocketChannel.writeFileRegion() does not handle the case where the
position of a FileRegion is non-zero properly.
Modifications:
- Improve SocketFileRegionTest so that it tests the cases where the file
transfer begins from the middle of the file
- Add another jlong parameter named 'base_off' so that we can take the
position of a FileRegion into account
Result:
Improved test passes. Corruption is gone.
Motivation:
While trying to merge our ChannelOutboundBuffer changes we've made last
week, I realized that we have quite a bit of conflicting changes at 4.1
and master. It was primarily because we added
ChannelOutboundBuffer.beforeAdd() and moved some logic there, such as
direct buffer conversion.
However, this is not possible with the changes we've made for 4.0. We
made ChannelOutboundBuffer final for example.
Maintaining multiple branch is already getting painful and having
different core will make it even worse, so I think we should keep the
differences between 4.0 and other branches minimal.
Modifications:
- Move ChannelOutboundBuffer.safeRelease() to ReferenceCountUtil
- Add ByteBufUtil.threadLocalBuffer()
- Backported from ThreadLocalPooledDirectByteBuf
- Make most methods in AbstractUnsafe final
- Add AbstractChannel.filterOutboundMessage() so that a transport can
convert a message to another (e.g. heap -> off-heap), and also
reject unsupported messages
- Move all direct buffer conversions to filterOutboundMessage()
- Move all type checks to filterOutboundMessage()
- Move AbstractChannel.checkEOF() to OioByteStreamChannel, because it's
the only place it is used at all
- Remove ChannelOutboundBuffer.current(Object), because it's not used
anymore
- Add protected direct buffer conversion methods to AbstractNioChannel
and AbstractEpollChannel so that they can be used by their subtypes
- Update all transport implementations according to the changes above
Result:
- The missing extension point in 4.0 has been added.
- AbstractChannel.filterOutboundMessage()
- Thanks to the new extension point, we moved all transport-specific
logic from ChannelOutboundBuffer to each transport implementation
- We can copy most of the transport implementations in 4.0 to 4.1 and
master now, so that we have much less merge conflict when we modify
the core.
Related issue: #2733
Motivation:
Unlike OpenSsl, Epoll lacks a couple useful availability checker
methods:
- ensureAvailability()
- unavailabilityCause()
Modifications:
Add missing methods
Result:
More ways to check the availability and to get the cause of
unavailability programatically.
Motivation:
When a ChannelOutboundBuffer contains a series of entries whose messages
are all empty buffers, EpollSocketChannel sometimes fails to remove
them. As a result, the result of the write(EmptyByteBuf) is never
notified, making the user application hang.
Modifications:
- Add ChannelOutboundBuffer.removeBytes(long) method that updates the
progress of the entries and removes them as much as the specified
number of written bytes. It also updates the reader index of
partially flushed buffer.
- Make both NioSocketChannel and EpollSocketChannel use it to reduce
code duplication
- Replace EpollSocketChannel.updateOutboundBuffer()
- Refactor EpollSocketChannel.doWrite() for simplicity
- Split doWrite() into doWriteSingle() and doWriteMultiple()
- Do not add a zero-length buffer to IovArray
- Do not perform any real I/O when the size of IovArray is 0
Result:
Another regression is gone.
- ChannelOutboundBuffer.Entry.buffers -> bufs for consistency
- Make Native.IOV_MAX final because it's a constant
- Naming changes
- FlushedMessageProcessor -> MessageProcessor just in case we can
reuse it for unflushed messages in the future
- Add ChannelOutboundBuffer.Entry.recycle() that does not return the
next entry, and use it wherever possible
- Javadoc clean-up
Motivation:
While benchmarking the native transport, I noticed that gathering write
is not as fast as expected. It was due to the fact that we have to do a
lot of array copies to put the buffer addresses into the iovec struct
array.
Modifications:
Introduce a new class called IovArray, which allows to fill buffers
directly into an off-heap array of iovec structs, so that it can be
passed over to JNI without any extra array copies.
Result:
Big performance improvement when doing gathering writes:
Before:
[nmaurer@xxx]~% wrk/wrk -H 'Host: localhost' -H 'Accept: text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,*/*;q=0.8' -H 'Connection: keep-alive' -d 120 -c 256 -t 16 --pipeline 256 http://xxx:8080/plaintext
Running 2m test @ http://xxx:8080/plaintext
16 threads and 256 connections
Thread Stats Avg Stdev Max +/- Stdev
Latency 23.44ms 16.37ms 259.57ms 91.77%
Req/Sec 181.99k 31.69k 304.60k 78.12%
346544071 requests in 2.00m, 46.48GB read
Requests/sec: 2887885.09
Transfer/sec: 396.59MB
After:
[nmaurer@xxx]~% wrk/wrk -H 'Host: localhost' -H 'Accept: text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,*/*;q=0.8' -H 'Connection: keep-alive' -d 120 -c 256 -t 16 --pipeline 256 http://xxx:8080/plaintext
Running 2m test @ http://xxx:8080/plaintext
16 threads and 256 connections
Thread Stats Avg Stdev Max +/- Stdev
Latency 21.93ms 16.33ms 305.73ms 92.34%
Req/Sec 194.56k 33.75k 309.33k 77.04%
369617503 requests in 2.00m, 49.57GB read
Requests/sec: 3080169.65
Transfer/sec: 423.00MB
Motivation:
73dfd7c01b introduced various test
failures because:
- EpollSocketChannel.doWrite() raised a NullPointerException when
notifying the write progress.
- ChannelOutboundBuffer.nioBuffers() did not expand the internal array
when the pending entries contained more than 1024 buffers, dropping
the remainder.
Modifications:
- Fix the NPE in EpollSocketChannel by removing an unnecessary progress
update
- Expand the thread-local buffer array if there is not enough room,
which was the original behavior dropped by the offending commit
Result:
Regression is gone.
Motivation:
We sometimes not use the correct exception message when throw it from the native code.
Modifications:
Fixed the message.
Result:
Correct message in exception
Motivation:
We have some inconsistency when handling writes. Sometimes we call ChannelOutboundBuffer.progress(...) also for complete writes and sometimes not. We should call it always.
Modifications:
Correctly call ChannelOuboundBuffer.progress(...) for complete and incomplete writes.
Result:
Consistent behavior
Motivation:
At the moment we use Get*ArrayElement all the time in the epoll transport which may be wasteful as the JVM may do a memory copy for this. For code-path that will get executed fast (without blocking) we should better make use of GetPrimitiveArrayCritical and ReleasePrimitiveArrayCritical as this signal the JVM that we not want to do any memory copy if not really needed. It is important to only do this on non-blocking code-path as this may even suspend the GC to disallow the JVM to move the arrays around.
See also http://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/technotes/guides/jni/spec/functions.html#GetPrimitiveArrayCritical
Modification:
Make use of GetPrimitiveArrayCritical / ReleasePrimitiveArrayCritical as replacement for Get*ArrayElement / Release*ArrayElement where possible.
Result:
Better performance due less memory copies.
Motivation:
In EpollSocketchannel.writeBytesMultiple(...) we loop over all buffers to see if we need to adjust the readerIndex for incomplete writes. We can skip this if we know that everything was written (a.k.a complete write).
Modification:
Use fast-path if all bytes are written and so no need to loop over buffers
Result:
Fast write path for the average use.
Motivation:
At the moment ChannelOutboundBuffer.nioBuffers() returns null if something is contained in the ChannelOutboundBuffer which is not a ByteBuf. This is a problem for two reasons:
1 - In the javadocs we state that it will never return null
2 - We may do a not optimal write as there may be things that could be written via gathering writes
Modifications:
Change ChannelOutboundBuffer.nioBuffers() to never return null but have it contain all ByteBuffer that were found before the non ByteBuf. This way we can do a gathering write and also conform to the javadocs.
Result:
Better speed and also correct implementation in terms of the api.
Motivation:
In the previous fix for #2667 I did introduce a bit overhead by calling setEpollOut() too often.
Modification:
Only call setEpollOut() if really needed and remove unused code.
Result:
Less overhead when saturate network.
Motivation:
As a DatagramChannel supports to write to multiple remote peers we must not close the Channel once a IOException accours as this error may be only valid for one remote peer.
Modification:
Continue writing on IOException.
Result:
DatagramChannel can be used even after an IOException accours during writing.
Motivation:
We need to continue write until we hit EAGAIN to make sure we not see an starvation
Modification:
Write until EAGAIN is returned
Result:
No starvation when using native transport with ET.
Motivation:
Because of a missing return statement we may produce a NPE when try to fullfill the connect ChannelPromise when it was fullfilled before.
Modification:
Add missing return statement.
Result:
No more NPE.
Motivation:
The handling of IOV_MAX was done in JNI code base which makes stuff really complicated to maintain etc.
Modifications:
Move handling of IOV_MAX to java code to simplify stuff
Result:
Cleaner code.
Motivation:
In our nio implementation we use write-spinning for maximize throughput, but in the native implementation this is not used.
Modification:
Respect writeSpinCount in native transport.
Result:
Better throughput
Motivation:
epoll transport fails on gathering write of more then 1024 buffers. As linux supports max. 1024 iov entries when calling writev(...) the epoll transport throws an exception.
Thanks again to @blucas to provide me with a reproducer and so helped me to understand what the issue is.
Modifications:
Make sure we break down the writes if to many buffers are uses for gathering writes.
Result:
Gathering writes work with any number of buffers
Motivation:
Currently it is impossible to build netty on linux system that not define SO_REUSEPORT even if it is supported.
Modification:
Define SO_REUSEPORT if not defined.
Result:
Possible to build on more linux dists.
Motivation:
We use the nanoTime of the scheduledTasks to calculate the milli-seconds to wait for a select operation to select something. Once these elapsed we check if there was something selected or some task is ready for processing. Unfortunally we not take into account scheduled tasks here so the selection loop will continue if only scheduled tasks are ready for processing. This will delay the execution of these tasks.
Modification:
- Check if a scheduled task is ready after selecting
- also make a tiny change in NioEventLoop to not trigger a rebuild if nothing was selected because the timeout was reached a few times in a row.
Result:
Execute scheduled tasks on time.
Motivation:
When we do a (env*)->GetObjectArrayElement(...) call we may created many local references which will only be cleaned up once we exist the native method. Thus a lot of memory can be used and so a StackOverFlow may be triggered. Beside this the JNI specification only say that an implementation must cope with 16 local references.
Modification:
Call (env*)->ReleaseLocalRef(...) to release the resource once not needed anymore.
Result:
Less memory usage and guard against StackOverflow
Motivation:
At the moment there is no simple way for a user to check if the native epoll transport can be used on the running platform. Thus the user can only try to instance it and catch any exception and fallback to nio transport.
Modification:
Add Epoll.isAvailable() which allows to check if epoll can be used.
Result:
User can easily check if epoll transport can be used or not
Motivation:
When using openjdk and oracle jdk's nio (while using the nio transport) the ServerSocketChannel uses SO_REUSEADDR by default. Our native transport should do the same to make it easier to switch between the different implementations and get the expected result.
Modification:
Change EpollServerSocketChannelConfig to set SO_REUSEADDR on the created socket.
Result:
SO_REUSEADDR is used by default on servers.
Motivation:
We need to map from ints to AbstractEpollChannel in EpollEventLoop but there is no need for box to Integer.
Modification:
Replace Map with IntObjectMap.
Result:
No more auto-boxing needed.
