Commit 587c3a2d19 fixed DoGetImage to
check windows against their backing drawables, rather than against the
screen dimensions, to prevent reading outside the bounds of redirected
windows' backing pixmaps (see bug #22804). Unfortunately, while
making that change I also removed the check that the rectangle is
contained within the bounds of the source window, which is a violation
of the specification:
If the drawable is a window, the window must be viewable, and it
must be the case that, if there were no inferiors or overlapping
windows, the specified rectangle of the window would be fully
visible on the screen *and wholly contained within the outside
edges of the window* (or a Match error results). Note that the
borders of the window can be included and read with this request.
(emphasis mine)
Reinstate the window dimension check, to return BadMatch if the
GetImage request falls outside the bounds of the window.
Fixes X Test Suite test XGetImage-15:
400|0 15 1 11:05:41|IC Start
200|0 15 11:05:41|TP Start
520|0 15 00005146 1 1|VSW5TESTSUITE PURPOSE 15
520|0 15 00005146 1 2|Assertion XGetImage-15.(A)
520|0 15 00005146 1 3|When the drawable is a window and the window is viewable
520|0 15 00005146 1 4|and it is not the case that given there were no inferiors or
520|0 15 00005146 1 5|overlapping windows the specified rectangle of the window
520|0 15 00005146 1 6|would be fully visible on the screen and wholly contained
520|0 15 00005146 1 7|within the outside edges of the window, then a BadMatch
520|0 15 00005146 1 8|error occurs.
520|0 15 00005146 1 9|METH: Create window which is not fully visible on the screen.
520|0 15 00005146 1 10|METH: Call XMapWindow to make sure the window is viewable.
520|0 15 00005146 1 11|METH: Call XGetImage with rectangle extending beyond edge of screen.
520|0 15 00005146 1 12|METH: Verify XGetImage return value is null.
520|0 15 00005146 1 13|METH: Verify that BadMatch error occurred.
520|0 15 00005146 1 14|METH: Create window which is fully visible on the screen.
520|0 15 00005146 1 15|METH: Call XMapWindow to make sure the window is viewable.
520|0 15 00005146 1 16|METH: Call XGetImage with rectangle extending beyond edge of window.
520|0 15 00005146 1 17|METH: Verify XGetImage return value is null.
520|0 15 00005146 1 18|METH: Verify that BadMatch error occurred.
520|0 15 00005146 1 19|REPORT: Got Success, Expecting BadMatch
520|0 15 00005146 1 20|REPORT: Null image not returned.
220|0 15 1 11:05:41|FAIL
Signed-off-by: Aaron Plattner <aplattner@nvidia.com>
Reviewed-by: Jeremy Huddleston <jeremyhu@apple.com>
Signed-off-by: Keith Packard <keithp@keithp.com>
8329afa59d