Commit Graph

8564 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Norman Maurer
d1d954da35 [#5866] HttpToHttp2ConnectionHandler / InboundHttp2ToHttpAdapter ignores STREAM_DEPENDENCY_ID and STREAM_WEIGHT.
Motivation:

HttpToHttp2ConnectionHandler.write(ctx, msg, promise) ignores HttpConversionUtil.ExtensionHeaderNames.STREAM_DEPENDENCY_ID header in outbound message. Beside this InboundHttp2ToHttpAdapter also not add the STREAM_DEPENDENCY_ID and STREAM_WEIGHT headers.

Modifications:

Respect STREAM_DEPENDENCY_ID and STREAM_WEIGHT

Result:

Correctly respect STREAM_DEPENDENCY_ID and STREAM_WEIGHT.
2016-10-03 18:05:50 +02:00
qiaodaimadelaowang
01af0baaf7 Fix typo in UnstableApi javadocs 2016-10-03 11:04:19 +02:00
Norman Maurer
1c588ce7e9 [#5841] Add test-case for mutual auth when using certificate chain
Motivation:

Add test-case for doing mutal auth with a certificate chain that holds more then one certificate.

Modifications:

Add test case

Result:

more tests.
2016-09-30 10:46:11 +02:00
radai-rosenblatt
15ac6c4a1f Clean-up unused imports
Motivation:

the build doesnt seem to enforce this, so they piled up

Modifications:

removed unused import lines

Result:

less unused imports

Signed-off-by: radai-rosenblatt <radai.rosenblatt@gmail.com>
2016-09-30 09:08:50 +02:00
Norman Maurer
cf8f6e3e2f [#5861] HttpUtil.getContentLength(HttpMessage, long) throws unexpected NumberFormatException
Motivation:

The Javadocs of HttpUtil.getContentLength(HttpMessage, long) and its int overload state that the provided default value is returned if the Content-Length value is not a number. NumberFormatException is thrown instead.

Modifications:

Correctly handle when the value is not a number.

Result:

API works as stated in javadocs.
2016-09-29 21:32:07 +02:00
Masaru Nomura
20da5383ce Upgrade JMH to 1.14.1
Motivation:
It'd be usually good to use the latest library version.

Modification:
Bumped JMH to the latest version as of today.

Result:
Now we use JMH version 1.14.1 for our benchmark.
2016-09-29 21:29:26 +02:00
Dominik Obermaier
5bb677e7c2 This PR fixes an issue with the PROXY protocol where the reader index of a consumed byte array was not set correctly.
Motivation:

When using the AF_UNIX PROXY protocol, the reader index was not set correctly after consuming the message bytes of the original header ByteBuf. This caused no immediate harm because after the codepath there is no consumer of the ByteBuf in the current implementation. It’s a bug nevertheless, because consumers of the ByteBuf for extensions (like TLVs, which are allowed by the PROXY protocol spec) would consume a ByteBuf that has a wrong readerIndex when using AF_UNIX instead of e.g. IPv4 (which has correct behaviour)

Modifications:

Increase the reader index of the ByteBuf after it was read

Result:

Correct and consistent behaviour of the AF_UNIX codepath
2016-09-29 21:21:01 +02:00
Norman Maurer
3240e97420 [#5862] Http2EventAdapter#onUnknownFrame(...) should throw Http2Exception
Motivation:

Http2EventAdapter implements the Http2FrameListener interface but implements the #onUnknownFrame(...) method without the interface's throws Http2Exception.

Modifications:

Add throws Http2Exception.

Result:

More correct method signature.
2016-09-29 14:22:13 +02:00
rdhabalia
789c9a53df Pre-increment leakCheckCnt to prevent false leak-detectation for very first time
Motivation:
ResourceLeakDetector reports leak for first call to open(obj) as its leakCheckCnt starts with value 0 and increment subsequently. with value of leakCheckCnt =0, it always returns ResourceLeak. Our application calls ResourceLeakDetector.open(obj) to validate Leak and it fails at very first call even though there is no leak in application.

Modifications:
ResourceLeakDetector.leakCheckCnt value will not be 0 while deriving leak and it will not return incorrect value of ResourceLeak.

Result:
Fix false leak report on first call on ResourceLeakDetector.
2016-09-29 14:13:33 +02:00
Roger Kapsi
149916d052 Adding ability omit the implicit #flush() call in EmbeddedChannel#writeOutbound() and
the implicit #fireChannelReadComplete() in EmbeddedChannel#writeInbound().

Motivation

We use EmbeddedChannels to implement a ProxyChannel of some sorts that shovels
messages between a source and a destination Channel. The latter are real network
channels (such as Epoll) and they may or may not be managed in a ChannelPool. We
could fuse both ends directly together but the EmbeddedChannel provides a nice
disposable section of a ChannelPipeline that can be used to instrument the messages
that are passing through the proxy portion.

The ideal flow looks abount like this:

source#channelRead() -> proxy#writeOutbound() -> destination#write()
source#channelReadComplete() -> proxy#flushOutbound() -> destination#flush()

destination#channelRead() -> proxy#writeInbound() -> source#write()
destination#channelReadComplete() -> proxy#flushInbound() -> source#flush()

The problem is that #writeOutbound() and #writeInbound() emit surplus #flush()
and #fireChannelReadComplete() events which in turn yield to surplus #flush()
calls on both ends of the pipeline.

Modifications

Introduce a new set of write methods that reain the same sematics as the #write()
method and #flushOutbound() and #flushInbound().

Result

It's possible to implement the above ideal flow.

Fix for EmbeddedChannel#ensureOpen() and Unit Tests for it

Some PR stuff.
2016-09-24 12:33:04 -07:00
buchgr
6a6d422702 Complete documentation of StreamBufferingEncoder.
Motivation:

The StreamBufferingEncoder is missing documentation of what happens
to buffered frames when it's closed.

Modifications:

Added this missing piece of documentation.

Result:

Improved documentation.
2016-09-23 16:39:31 -07:00
olim7t
3a8b8c9219 Consolidate flushes even when no read in progress
Motivation:

Currently FlushConsolidationHandler only consolidates if a read loop is
active for a Channel, otherwise each writeAndFlush(...) call will still
be flushed individually. When these calls are close enough, it can be
beneficial to consolidate them even outside of a read loop.

Modifications:

When we allow a flush to "go through", don't perform it immediately, but
submit it on the channel's executor. Under high pressure, this gives
other writes a chance to enqueue before the task gets executed, and so
we flush multiple writes at once.

Result:

Lower CPU usage and less context switching.
2016-09-23 15:27:03 -07:00
Norman Maurer
5986c229c4 [#5833] Ensure direct memory is released when DirectPoolArena is collected
Motivation:

We need to ensure we release all direct memory once the DirectPoolArena is collected. Otherwise we may never reclaim the memory and so leak memory.

Modifications:

Ensure we destroy all PoolChunk memory when DirectPoolArena is collected.

Result:

Free up unreleased memory when DirectPoolArena is collected.
2016-09-23 15:20:59 -07:00
Moses Nakamura
0d2baaf6ae codec-http2: Let users configure per-frame logs
Motivation:

codec-http2 is really loud!

Modification:

Allow users to select how to log in the Http2Codec.

Result:

We can run Http2Codec and log however we like.
2016-09-23 14:58:23 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
506ac2ca71 NetUtil.bytesToIpAddress bug
Motivation:
NetUtil.bytesToIpAddress does not correctly translate IPv4 address to String. Also IPv6 addresses may not follow minimization conventions when converting to a String (see rfc 5952).

Modifications:
- NetUtil.bytesToIpAddress should correctly handle negative byte values for IPv4
- NetUtil.bytesToIpAddress should leverage existing to string conversion code in NetUtil

Result:
Fixes https://github.com/netty/netty/issues/5821
2016-09-22 17:06:21 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
dd1ba2a252 HttpObjectDecoder resetRequested not updated after reset
Motivation:
HttpObjectDecoder maintains a resetRequested flag which is used to determine if internal state should be reset when a decode occurs. However after a reset is done the resetRequested flag is not set to false. This leads to all data after this point being discarded.

Modifications:
- Set resetRequested to false when a reset is done

Result:
HttpObjectDecoder can still function after a reset.
2016-09-22 10:58:44 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
4145fae919 HTTP/2 HPACK Decoder VarInt Improvement
Motivation:
HTTP/2 Decoder#decodeULE128 current will tolerate more bytes than necessary when attempted to detect overflow. The usage of this method also currently requires an additional overflow conditional.

Modifications:
- Integrate the first byte into Decoder#decodeULE128 which allows us to detect overflow reliably and avoid overflow checks outside of this method.

Result:
Less conditionals and earlier overflow detection in Decoder#decodeULE128
2016-09-22 00:01:54 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
9b6cbf8ab1 Fix typo for max leak records system property
Motivation:
For the leak profile we attempted to increase the number of leak hints that were retained to make debugging easier, but there was a typo.

Modifications:
- maxRecord -> maxRecords

Result:
Fix typo in pom.xml so leak profile provides more context for leaks.
2016-09-21 23:15:27 -07:00
Roger Kapsi
9a18159bfe Catch+fire Exceptions thrown from SniHandler's select() method
Motivation

Give the user the ability to back out from SNI negoations.

Modifications

Put a try-catch around the select() call and re-fire any caught Exceptions.

Result

Fixes #5787
2016-09-19 16:10:24 -07:00
Frédérik Rouleau
8d6f0a3ce4 Improve SctpMessageCompletionHandler
Motivation:

Avoid multiple search in fragments map

Modifications:

Replace usage of Map.containsKey by Map.remove

Result:

During packet process, fragment is only search once in the map instead of 3 times in the previous worst case
2016-09-19 08:23:00 -07:00
Norman Maurer
4a5340eae7 Fix IndexOutOfBoundsException in HelloWorldHttp2Handler
Motivation:

We need to duplicate the buffer before passing it to writeBytes(...) as it will increase the readerIndex().

Modifications:

Call duplicate().

Result:

No more IndexOutOfBoundsException when runing the multiplex example.
2016-09-16 16:21:53 -07:00
Norman Maurer
e94db103c9 Ensure flowController().writePendingBytes() is triggered when writing response in example
Motivation:

We called ctx.flush() which is not correct as it will not call flowController().writePendingBytes().

Modifications:

Call flush(ChannelHandlerContext) and so also call flowController().writePendingBytes().

Result:

Correct http2 example
2016-09-16 16:20:46 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
e3fbfe5641 HTTP/2 example upgrade refcnt bug
Motivation:
Http2ServerInitializer uses a SimpleChannelHandler in an attempt to ease putting an HttpObjectAggregator in the pipeline when no upgrade is attempted. However the message is double released because it is fired up the pipeline (which will be released) and also released by SimpleChannelHandler in a finally block.

Modifications:
- Retain the message if we fire it up the pipeline

Result:
HTTP/2 examples don't encounter a reference count error if no upgrade was attempted.
2016-09-16 09:18:12 -07:00
Norman Maurer
3c62a20519 Revert "Ensure we only call debugData.release() if we called debugData.retain()"
This reverts commit 4beb075dd3.
2016-09-16 08:51:11 -07:00
Norman Maurer
2c4a7a2539 [#5800] Support any FileRegion implementation when using epoll transport
Motivation:

At the moment only DefaultFileRegion is supported when using the native epoll transport.

Modification:

- Add support for any FileRegion implementation
- Add test case

Result:

Also custom FileRegion implementation are supported when using the epoll transport.
2016-09-15 23:03:37 -07:00
Christopher O'Toole
c57d4bed91 Add HttpServerKeepAliveHandler
Motivation:

As discussed in #5738, developers need to concern themselves with setting
connection: keep-alive on the response as well as whether to close a
connection or not after writing a response.  This leads to special keep-alive
handling logic in many different places.  The purpose of the HttpServerKeepAliveHandler
is to allow developers to add this handler to their pipeline and therefore
free themselves of having to worry about the details of how Keep-Alive works.

Modifications:

Added HttpServerKeepAliveHandler to the io.netty.handler.codec.http package.

Result:

Developers can start using HttpServerKeepAliveHandler in their pipeline instead
of worrying about when to close a connection for keep-alive.
2016-09-15 15:59:21 -07:00
Moses Nakamura
da8734a6f9 codec-http2: Mark requests as chunked in Http2ServerDowngrader
Motivation:

Http2ServerDowngrader doesn't mark chunked requests as chunked, even
though the natural conversion from http/2 requests to http/1.1 requests
is to chunked ones.

Modifications:

Mark requests that aren't already complete as chunked.

Result:

Requests will be chunked, and can later be aggregated if necessary.
2016-09-15 15:58:40 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
0b5e75a614 IdleStateHandler volatile member variables
Motivation:
IdleStateHandler has a number of volatile member variables which are only accessed from the EventLoop thread. These do not have to be volatile. The accessibility of these member variables are not consistent between private and package private. The state variable can also use a byte instead of an int.

Modifications:
- Remove volatile from member variables
- Change access to private for member variables
- Change state from int to byte

Result:
IdleStateHandler member variables cleaned up.
2016-09-15 10:27:29 -07:00
buchgr
908464f161 make the http2 codec void promise ready.
Motivation:

Void promises need special treatment, as they don't behave like normal promises. One
cannot add a listener to a void promise for example.

Modifications:

Inspected the code for addListener() calls, and added extra logic for void promises
where necessary. Essentially, when writing a frame with a void promise, any errors
are reported via the channel pipeline's exceptionCaught event.

Result:

The HTTP/2 codec has better support for void promises.
2016-09-15 09:19:57 -07:00
Scott Mitchell
e3462a79c7 MessageAggregator Potential Leak
Motivation:
MessageAggregator has a potential to leak if a new message is received before the existing message has completed, and if a HttpContent is received but maxContentLength has been exceeded, or the content length is too long.

Modifications:

- Make the HttpObjectAggregator more robust to leaks
- Reduce dependance on handlingOversizedMessage but instead rely on the more general check of a null currentMessage

Result:
More robust MessageAggregator with less chance of leaks
2016-09-14 10:13:49 -07:00
Norman Maurer
eb7f751ba5 Log less confusing message when try to load native library
Motivation:

At the moment we log very confusing messages when trying to load a native library which kind of suggest that the whole loading process failed even if just one mechanism failed and the library could be loaded at the end.

Modifications:

Make the mesage less confusing and also log a successful load of the native library.

Result:

Less confusing logs.
2016-09-13 17:15:47 -07:00
Norman Maurer
4a18a143d2 Only set lastReadTime if an read actually happened before in IdleStateHandler.
Motivation:

IdleStateHandler and ReadTimeoutHandler could mistakely not fire an event even if no channelRead(...) call happened.

Modifications:

Only set lastReadTime if a read happened before.

Result:

More correct IdleStateHandler / ReadTimeoutHandler.
2016-09-13 16:57:29 -07:00
Fabian Lange
f375772ff0 Remove OSGi import of JCTools since it is shaded.
Motivation:

Since netty shaded JCTools the OSGi manifest no longer is correct. It claims to
have an optional import "org.jctools.queues;resolution:=optional,org.jctools.qu
eues.atomic;resolution:=optional,org.jctools.util;resolution:=optional"
However since it is shaded, this is no longer true.
This was noticed when making JCTools a real bundle and netty resolved it as
optional import.

Modifications:

Modify the generated manifest by no longer analyzing org.jctools for imports.
A manual setting of sun.misc as optional was required.

Result:

Netty OSGi bundle will no longer interfere with a JCTools bundle.
2016-09-13 15:21:34 -07:00
Norman Maurer
4beb075dd3 Ensure we only call debugData.release() if we called debugData.retain()
Motivation:

We need to ensure we only call debugData.release() if we called debugData.retain(), otherwise we my see an IllegalReferenceCountException.

Modifications:

Only call release() if we called retain().

Result:

No more IllegalReferenceCountException possible.
2016-09-12 06:47:38 -07:00
Norman Maurer
51629245d0 Call debugData.retain() before we forward the frame to the pipeline
Motivation:

We need to call debugData.retain() before we forward the frame to the pipeline as ByteToMessageDecoder will call release() on the buffer.

Modifications:

Correctly retain debugData and fix the unit test to test for it.

Result:

No more IllegalReferenceCountException when using the Http2FrameCodec.
2016-09-12 06:45:13 -07:00
ChuntaoLu
9008e72c2b Fix javadoc
Removes unmatched brace
2016-09-12 06:43:10 -07:00
Gaston Tonietti
245fb52c90 Provide extra info together with handshake complete event.
Motivation:

As described in #5734

Before this change, if the server had to do some sort of setup after a
handshake was completed based on handshake's information, the only way
available was to wait (in a separate thread) for the handshaker to be
added as an attribute to the channel. Too much hassle.

Modifications:

Handshake completed event need to be stateful now, so I've added a tiny
class holding just the HTTP upgrade request and the selected subprotocol
which is fired as an event after the handshake has finished.
I've also deprecated the old enum used as stateless event and I left the
code that fires it for backward compatibility. It should be removed in
the next mayor release.

Result:

It should be much simpler now to do initialization stuff based on
subprotocol or request headers on handshake completion. No asynchronous
waiting needed anymore.
2016-09-11 17:52:07 +02:00
Norman Maurer
d2389a9339 [#5762] HTTP/2: SETTINGS_HEADER_TABLE_SIZE should be an unsigned int
Motivation:

he HTTP/2 spec demands that the max value for SETTINGS_HEADER_TABLE_SIZE should be an unsigned 32-bit integer.

Modifications:

Change the limit to unsigned 32-bit integer and add tests.

Result:

Complient to rfc.
2016-09-09 13:20:32 +02:00
buchgr
67d3a78123 Reduce bytecode size of PlatformDependent0.equals.
Motivation:

PP0.equals has a bytecode size of 476. This is above the default inlining threshold of OpenJDK.

Modifications:

Slightly change the method to reduce the bytecode size by > 50% to 212 bytes.

Result:

The bytecode size is dramatically reduced, making the method a candidate for inlining.
The relevant code in our application (gRPC) that relies heavily on equals comparisons,
runs some ~10% faster. The Netty JMH benchmark shows no performance regression.

Current 4.1:

PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual      10  avgt   20     7.836 ±   0.113  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual      50  avgt   20    16.889 ±   4.284  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual     100  avgt   20    15.601 ±   0.296  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual    1000  avgt   20    95.885 ±   1.992  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual   10000  avgt   20   824.429 ±  12.792  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual  100000  avgt   20  8907.035 ± 177.844  ns/op

With this change:

PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual      10  avgt   20      5.616 ±   0.102  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual      50  avgt   20     17.896 ±   0.373  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual     100  avgt   20     14.952 ±   0.210  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual    1000  avgt   20     94.799 ±   1.604  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual   10000  avgt   20    834.996 ±  17.484  ns/op
PlatformDependentBenchmark.unsafeBytesEqual  100000  avgt   20   8757.421 ± 187.555  ns/op
2016-09-09 07:57:41 +02:00
Norman Maurer
05fb698166 [#5759] Allow websocket extensions in websocketx example.
Motivation:

As we use compression in the websocketx example we need to allow extensions as ohterwise the example not works.

Modifications:

Allow extensions.

Result:

websocketx example does work.
2016-09-07 13:57:27 +02:00
Norman Maurer
6bbf32134a Log more details if notification of promise fails in PromiseNotifier and AbstractChannelHandlerContext
Motivation:

To make it easier to debug why notification of a promise failed we should log extra info and make it consistent.

Modifications:

- Create a new PromiseNotificationUtil that has static methods that can be used to try notify a promise and log.
- Reuse this in AbstractChannelHandlerContext, ChannelOutboundBuffer and PromiseNotifier

Result:

Easier to debug why a promise could not be notified.
2016-09-07 06:55:38 +02:00
Victor Noël
8566fd1019 Add startTls parameter to SslContextBuilder
Motivation:

There is an incoherence in terms of API when one wants to use
startTls: without startTls one can use the SslContextBuilder's
method newHandler, but with startTls, the developper is forced
to call directly the SslHandler constructor.

Modifications:

Introduce startTls as a SslContextBuilder parameter as well as a
member in SslContext (and thus Jdk and OpenSsl implementations!).
Always use this information to call the SslHandler constructor.
Use false by default, in particular in deprecated constructors of
the SSL implementations.
The client Context use false by default

Results:

Fixes #5170 and more generally homogenise the API so that
everything can be done via SslContextBuilder.
2016-09-06 11:29:10 +02:00
Roger Kapsi
b604a22395 Expose the ChannelHandlerContext from SniHandler's select() step to the user.
Motivation

I'm looking to harden our SSL impl. a little bit and add some guards agaist certain types of abuse. One can think of invalid hostname strings in the SNI extenstion or invalid SNI handshakes altogether. This will require measuring, velocity tracking and other things.

Modifications

Adding a protected `lookup(ctx, hostname)` method that is called from SniHandler's `select(...)` method which users can override and implement custom behaviour. The default implementation will simply call the AsyncMapper.

Result

It's possible to get a hold onto the ChannelHandlerContext. Users can override that method and do something with it right there or they can delegate it to something else. SniHandler is happy as long as a `Future<SslContext>` is being returned.
2016-09-06 07:29:12 +02:00
William Blackie
e3aca1f3d6 CorsHandler to respect http connection (keep-alive) header.
Motivation:

The CorsHandler currently closes the channel when it responds to a preflight (OPTIONS)
request or in the event of a short circuit due to failed validation.

Especially in an environment where there's a proxy in front of the service this causes
unnecessary connection churn.

Modifications:

CorsHandler now uses HttpUtil to determine if the connection should be closed
after responding and to set the Connection header on the response.

Result:

Channel will stay open when the CorsHandler responds unless the client specifies otherwise
or the protocol version is HTTP/1.0
2016-09-06 07:18:53 +02:00
Norman Maurer
dfa3bbbf00 Add support for Client Subnet in DNS Queries (RFC7871)
Motivation:

RFC7871 defines an extension which allows to request responses for a given subset.

Modifications:

- Add DnsOptPseudoRrRecord which can act as base class for extensions based on EDNS(0) as defined in RFC6891
- Add DnsOptEcsRecord to support the Client Subnet in DNS Queries extension
- Add tests

Result:

Client Subnet in DNS Queries extension is now supported.
2016-09-06 07:16:57 +02:00
Norman Maurer
bd7806dd4f Ensure SSLEngineTest works on different jvm versions.
Motivation:

af632278d2 introduced a test which only worked on some jvm versions and specific os'es.

Modifications:

Fix test to work on different java versions and os'es

Result:

No flacky test.
2016-09-05 21:07:48 +02:00
Norman Maurer
af632278d2 Ensure we not sent duplicate certificates when using OpenSslEngine
Motivation:

We need to ensure we not set duplicated certificates when using OpenSslEngine.

Modifications:

- Skip first cert in chain when set the chain itself and so not send duplicated certificates
- Add interopt unit tests to ensure no duplicates are send.

Result:

No more duplicates.
2016-09-05 15:05:17 +02:00
Norman Maurer
147d427adc [#5712] Allow clients to override userDefinedWritabilityIndex from AbstractTrafficShapingHandler
Motivation:

AbstractTrafficShapingHandler has a package-private method called "userDefinedWritabilityIndex()" which a user may need to override if two sub-classes wants to be used in the ChannelPipeline.

Modifications:

Mark method protected.

Result:

Easier to extend AbstractTrafficShapingHandler.
2016-09-05 12:29:40 +02:00
buchgr
4af6855695 Remove @Deprecated for primitive WriteWaterMark getters and setters
Motivation:

For use cases that demand frequent updates of the write watermarks, an
API that requires immutable WriteWaterMark objects is not ideal, as it
implies a lot of object allocation.

For example, the HTTP/2 child channel API uses write watermarks for outbound
flow control and updates the write watermarks on every DATA frame write.

Modifications:

Remote @Deprecated tag from primitive getters and setters, however the corresponding
channel options remain deprecated.

Result:

Primitive getters and setters for write watermarks are no longer marked @Deprecated.
2016-09-05 10:26:05 +02:00
Norman Maurer
3103f0551c Share code between retain(...) and release(...) implementations.
Motivation:

We can share the code in retain() and retain(...) and also in release() and release(...).

Modifications:

Share code.

Result:

Less duplicated code.
2016-09-02 21:53:10 +02:00